People often ask authors which character is their favorite to write. The answer usually surprises them.
It’s rarely the hero. Sometimes it’s the villain.
Not because we admire them, of course, but because creating a believable villain is one of the greatest challenges a writer can face. Heroes are often guided by love, hope, loyalty, and courage. Villains, on the other hand, force us to explore the darker corners of human nature—pride, jealousy, greed, fear, and the desperate need for control. They ask difficult questions. What makes an ordinary person cross a moral line?
At what point does ambition become obsession? Can love become possessiveness? Can pain become cruelty?
As a writer, I don’t believe villains wake up in the morning thinking, “Today I’ll become the bad guy.”
Like all of us, they believe they are justified. They make one choice. Then another. And before long, they’ve become someone capable of hurting the people around them without remorse.
Writing those moments can be surprisingly uncomfortable.
There were times while writing the Rostoff Family Saga when I found myself shaking my head at Elizabeth Rostoff. She is, without question, one of the most difficult characters I have ever written.
She manipulates. She deceives. She places her own desires above the happiness of those she claims to love.
More than once, I wanted to reach into the manuscript and tell her to stop. Of course, she never listened.
Because once characters become real, they begin making their own decisions. As strange as that may sound, many writers will understand exactly what I mean.
Elizabeth taught me something important. A memorable villain isn’t frightening because they are powerful.
They are frightening because they are believable.
History—and life itself—reminds us that the greatest harm is often caused not by monsters, but by ordinary people making selfish choices. That is what I wanted Elizabeth to represent. Not evil in its most dramatic form. But the quiet damage one person can inflict on an entire family when pride and self-interest replace compassion.
Ironically, writing a villain also made me appreciate my heroes even more. Without darkness, courage cannot shine. Without betrayal, forgiveness loses its meaning. Without obstacles, triumph feels unearned.
Every hero needs someone to challenge them. Every family saga needs conflict. Every great story needs a reason for readers to keep turning the pages.
In the end, I don’t write villains because I enjoy cruelty. I write them because they remind us why kindness matters. They make us appreciate honesty, loyalty, sacrifice, and love.
And perhaps that is the greatest purpose any villain can serve. They don’t teach us how to become better people. They remind us why we should.
Before I close, I’d like to share a small glimpse of Elizabeth Rostoff.
I won’t reveal too much—after all, every villain deserves to make their own first impression—but I hope this brief excerpt offers a window into the woman who challenged not only the Rostoff family, but me as an author.
Writing Elizabeth was never easy. There were days when I disliked every decision she made. There were moments when I wished she would choose compassion over manipulation, honesty over deception, love over control. But if she had, she wouldn’t have been Elizabeth. And perhaps that’s the greatest lesson she taught me.
As authors, we don’t get to choose only the characters we’d enjoy having over for dinner. We must also create the ones who make our heroes stronger, our readers angrier, and our stories impossible to forget.
So, I’d like to introduce you to one of the most unforgettable women I’ve ever written.
Excerpt from “New Dawn“
Her Grace, Princess Elizabeth, Elizaveta Andreevna Rostoff, sat in her favorite chair embroidered with Monarch’s golden lily, engrossed in a book. For a moment, Dmitry stood unnoticed and studied his aging mother.
At sixty-four, she was still beautiful with her thick white-silver hair cut in a stylish bob. His eyes traveled past the long column of her neck and stopped on her arresting face. Slashing cheekbones, high forehead, Greek nose.
She looked as if chiseled from a piece of marble, exquisite as it was cold. Regal was the only word to describe Her Grace Elizabeth.
Sensing intrusion, his mother sharply turned her head left and looked up. Straight at him. Her intense and brutally intelligent eyes held him captive. They always reminded him of a stormy sky—angry, cold, majestic.
“Hello, Mother.” Dmitry greeted her in Russian, for Elizabeth forbade any other language inside the house. Fluent in five—French, English, German, Italian and Spanish—Dmitry never heard her speak any other language except her native tongue in her domain. Her mausoleum.
“Hello, Dmitry,” Elizabeth replied in the frosty alto he loved and hated for as long as he could remember.
“I hope nothing’s wrong with the business?” she inquired dryly.
Oh, how predictable.
Dmitry barely controlled his disgust.
Business, her beloved company. It always comes first. Damn her.
Officially, Elizabeth retired from the family business several years ago after he took over Rostoff & Co. Correction—after she entrusted it to him with great reluctance and wariness. But Elizabeth was still the president, and she controlled the board of directors single-handedly and unquestionably, leaving her only son the chair and position of the CEO.
Although she preferred to live in her California manor, the headquarters of Rostoff & Co. were located in New York—Midtown Manhattan, to be precise—in the old building his grandfather bought and painstakingly rebuilt for the first store during The Roaring Twenties. Since then, it was expanded several times to accommodate the growing business enterprise soon to become a nationwide chain of jewelry stores. Rostoff’s gems, especially diamonds, were famous throughout the world, unrivaled by their beauty and value.
They were also the only thing Elizabeth loved and cared about with passion.
“Rest assured, Mother, your beloved business is all right.” More harsh and brusque than was permitted by Elizabeth’s rules, Dmitry’s reply triggered an immediate reaction. As two perfect brows raised, the color of her eyes deepened to the shade of pewter.
“Don’t you dare take that tone with me, Dmitry.” The ice in her voice may well have extinguished an inferno.
She looked at him pointedly, waiting for an apology. More than anything, he wanted to turn around and leave in silent protest. But such a behavior was adolescent rebellion, silly and pointless. Dmitry never resorted to it, even in his early teenage years. He wasn’t about to start now.
After all, who knew Elizabeth better than he did? He taught himself early on to never expect from her what she was unable to give, simple warmth and compassion.
“Forgive me, Mother,” he said dryly. “It was rude of me.”
Elizabeth nodded regally. She held out her hand, queen to a peasant. Dmitry bent forward and gingerly kissed it. As soon as his lips touched her skin, she withdrew her fingers. She didn’t like to be touched by anybody, even her own son. As if such an act as physical contact with another body might sully her perfection.
Dmitry wondered how she permitted her husband to be intimate with her and touch her long enough to conceive him. She undoubtedly hated every second. And once again, he wondered if his mother’s obsession with power and her passion for precious stones replaced in her heart the most natural needs. And if it was enough.
“Now, explain your sudden request for this late meeting.” Elizabeth’s calm, detached voice interrupted his musings.
“I have some news,” Dmitry replied calmly and detached. He was his mother’s son, after all.
“Sit,” Elizabeth ordered, pointing to a chair nearby, directly opposite her own.
Dmitry sat, carefully adjusting his tailored trousers, and holding his back straight and his head high. He looked at Elizabeth’s classically beautiful face and into her smoky eyes, and winced inwardly because he realized revealing his secret about Svetlana to her was simply unbearable, like stripping naked before her eyes. Only he wouldn’t be stripping his body, but his soul. And Dmitry hated that with every fiber of his being.
If not for this damned baby, he thought bitterly, his hate for this tiny unwelcome intruder increasing tenfold. He preferred to grieve in silence, to mourn the woman he loved in the sanctuary of his own home, alone. But no, Dmitry fumed impotently, as he was cheated out of even this small luxury, and all because of the baby. This nameless, useless, five-days-old baby.
“Mother, I’m afraid what I’m going to tell you will be an unpleasant surprise.”
Elizabeth didn’t react at all, only kept staring at him, her gunmetal-gray eyes cold and sharp.
He counted ten seconds then said, “Do you remember three years ago when I flew to Moscow to clean up the mess with customs?”
She nodded, her face remaining emotionless.
Dmitry pressed his lips tight before continuing, “I met a woman.” His voice betrayed him, catching on the last word. He fell silent, avoiding her face and those brutal eyes of hers. “She…I…”
“Stop mumbling like an imbecile, Dmitry. You met a woman, you had an affair. At least be man enough to say it,” Elizabeth hissed through her perfect teeth, her distaste quite apparent.
Dmitry jerked back as if she had slapped his face.
“Svetlana Zakharova,” she continued in a dry, almost bored voice. “Ballerina, born December tenth, nineteen sixty-five in Moscow, orphaned two years later. Entered Moscow Ballet Academy on special scholarship for poor gifted children in nineteen seventy-three. Prima ballerina of The Bolshoi Theatre since nineteen eighty.” Elizabeth stated the facts ruthlessly, calmly, brutally.
Shocked, Dmitry looked at her in horrified silence. Each and every word out of her mouth was another nail hammered into the coffin of his disillusionment. Heat crawled up his neck. He felt stupid, mortified.
“You knew? All this time—”
“Of course I knew.” She snorted but managed to do it almost delicately, for snorting was considered beneath her aristocratic statue and very unladylike. “Do you think I’m a fool? I knew all along about—”
“Don’t,” Dmitry’s cut her off with just one word. Softly, almost inaudibly.
He kept his eyes on her face that suddenly was bleached of any color. After a long, charged moment, Elizabeth took a deep breath and visibly recovered.
Took you long enough, Mother.
Was it small of him to draw satisfaction from it? He shrugged inwardly.
To hell with it.
“All right.” She bowed out semi-graciously. “I won’t say anything more. But it has to stop, Dmitry. Immediately. It went on for too long. May I remind you, in case you forgot, that you are a married man? You have a son, for goodness’ sake.” Then she stated coldly, with brutal finality, “Three years should be enough.”
Dmitry exploded. “How would you know?!”
He was so angry he forgot the cardinal rule of Elizabeth’s household and slid from Russian into English.
“You never loved anybody in your life. I bet you never lost your calm demeanor, not to mention your sense.”
He rose from his chair and towered over her, his hands white knuckled.
“Have you ever felt so happy, so overwhelmed, so gloriously in love that nothing mattered except being together? Have you ever had the absolute knowledge of the one and only person created by God just for you? Have you wished to spend all your days and nights together and even that wouldn’t be long enough?” His voice rose to a shout and he failed to stop himself. “You’ve never known what passion is, have you, Mother? You never lost yourself or your precious self-control in the arms of a lover even for a split second. Sometimes I wonder if you’re human at all.”
A sharp wince contorted her face.
Too close to the truth?
“That’s enough,” she snapped in English, her voice a harsh whisper.
Thank you for stepping behind the scenes with me today.
Writing villains may be one of the hardest parts of storytelling, but it has also taught me that even the darkest characters can illuminate the very best qualities of the heroes who stand against them.
Until next time,
Happy reading,
Stella May